A practical editorial framework for protecting the integrity of the scholarly record, handling concerns fairly, and maintaining transparent journal policies.
Editorial Integrity
Editors are custodians of the scholarly record. Clear policies, consistent processes, documented decisions and fair treatment of authors and reviewers are essential to credible publishing.
Require authorship to reflect substantial scholarly contribution and encourage transparent contribution statements. Journals should have procedures for authorship changes and disputes.
State how similarity screening is used and distinguish legitimate text overlap from plagiarism, duplicate publication, salami slicing and inappropriate recycling.
Require relevant disclosures from authors, reviewers and editors, and establish recusal procedures where impartial editorial handling could reasonably be questioned.
Editorial decisions should be based on scholarly merit and journal scope, protected from inappropriate commercial, institutional, political or personal influence.
Every journal should publish clear policies covering:
Record the allegation, manuscript/article details, evidence supplied and relevant correspondence. Avoid premature conclusions.
Apply the journal's published policies, identify conflicts, preserve confidentiality and seek clarification or evidence where necessary.
Where appropriate, give affected parties an opportunity to respond and keep an auditable record of the editorial process.
Use a correction, expression of concern, retraction or other transparent notice when warranted. Notices should be linked clearly to the affected article.
Possible fabrication, falsification, unethical research, manipulated images, undisclosed competing interests or serious authorship concerns require careful investigation. Editors should distinguish concerns they can resolve editorially from matters requiring institutional investigation.
Publish a route for complaints and appeals, define who reviews them, manage conflicts of interest and communicate outcomes. An appeal should examine whether the editorial process and decision were properly applied rather than guarantee reversal.
Ethics policies are most effective when they are visible before submission, applied consistently during review and supported by transparent post-publication procedures.
Receive updates on training, conferences, editorial resources, opportunities and scholarly publishing developments.